San Diego FC’s head coach, Mikey Varas, called it when he spoke to the media earlier in the week before the match against Minnesota United. “It’s going to be a game where having the ball isn’t going to be a metric of success. It’s going to be what happens in the two boxes.” Varas claimed.

The difference between the two teams was one scored on their opportunities, and the other did not. That is soccer, and sometimes that’s how it goes. So, what went wrong for SDFC in a match they dominated but lost 1-3, snapping a six-match unbeaten streak?

Let’s dive in.

St. Clair Showcases Flair

As fans of the game, we often like to look at the stats to tell us the story of the game. We look at things like ‘shots on target’ and xG (expected goals). While there are many nuances to the game’s eventual outcome, one cannot be ignored – goalkeeper saves. Minnesota keeper Dayne St. Clair had a lot of them, 12 to be exact.

One can argue that SDFC did everything right, except for the score. After all, they stayed true to their identity, holding and possessing the ball, aggressively pressing and fighting for possession when they didn’t have it, and using their chances to counterattack. Anders Dreyer and Ahmad Pellegrino both found opportunities on goal, which they should have put away if not for the incredible saves from St. Clair.

“The first half was quite extraordinary. It was probably the best football we’ve played against a really good team,” Varas said in the postgame press conference.

The Canadian international and leading Goalkeeper of the Year candidate had to make six saves in the first half alone. The always clinical finisher, Dreyer, could not capitalize on his opportunities as the Dane appeared a little off for the entire match. Could it have been an international break hangover? Maybe. One thing is for sure: nothing can be taken away from an incredible performance by the MNUFC goalkeeper.

San Diego’s Woes at Home

There is an unusual pattern forming for a team that is in first place in their division – their home record. They are 7-4-5 (W-L-T) at home and 10-4-0 away. In the last five home matches, SDFC’s record is 1 win, 2 losses, and 2 ties. How can a team that is having so much success in their season still come away sitting in first place after a dismal record at Snapdragon Stadium, where they’ve only scored three goals and conceded five in their last five matches?

The answer would be the away record. In fact, San Diego FC has won its last seven matches on the road. Maybe it’s the underdog mentality that fuels the fire in the players. Perhaps the more reasonable explanation is the large sample size of game tape the visiting team can study.

Whether home or away, SDFC has maintained its style of play. The element of surprise when it comes to San Diego’s game plan is minimal. The difference is that the home team usually plays with a more aggressive style of play, which SDFC is very good at taking advantage of in their counterattacking prowess and clinical finishing.

Conversely, when a team comes to play in San Diego, most tend to play a more conservative game. Absorb the pressure, dig in defensively, and get out of Snapdragon Stadium with a point. Three, if the game presents opportunities on the other end of the field. It’s worked for other teams, so it must be the way to play against San Diego FC when you’re the away opponent.

Not Surprised by Minnesota

Minnesota did just that. A team that is comfortable giving up possession, sitting back, and absorbing the pressure to try and score on a counterattack. SDFC expected this kind of gameplay from Minnesota, but still could not break through.

“It was the exact game picture that we were expecting. What we wanted to do was make them uncomfortable in their structure, ensure their defenders were turned towards their own goal frequently, and have the goalkeeper make a lot of good saves. I think we did that”, Varas stated.

With four games left in the season, SDFC must figure out how to improve its creativity to become more dangerous up front. A lack of a true number nine still seems to be a glaring issue as Marcus Ingvartsen continues to battle injuries, while Corey Baird and Amahl Pellegrino haven’t been productive given their small sample size.

Baja Cup Friendly: Realistic Expectations

In what is being called the ‘Baja Cup’, SDFC and Club Tijuana Xolos will meet in an exhibition match to celebrate soccer culture in the border region between Mexico and the United States. Both teams are coming off of weekend league matches, with more coming this weekend. Both are anticipated to play mostly backup roles.

SDFC will focus on “making our squad bigger and giving some guys some playing time,” Varas said. It’s a great opportunity for players to showcase themselves, much like Manu Duah did earlier this year. Even though the match is a friendly, the players and the club take it seriously.

San Diego FC head coach Mikey Varas acknowledged there’s “a little bit of a double mission” this week. He’s split the roster into two groups: one preparing to face Tijuana, the other training with Atlanta in mind. Both squads will travel to Atlanta later in the week, with the youngsters hoping that a competitive showing against the Xolos will provide an opportunity to play first-team minutes in Atlanta.

Tuesday’s clash introduces a new five-year collaboration between San Diego FC and Club Tijuana, centered around an annual matchup that celebrates the cross-border soccer heritage of the region. The competition becomes the first ongoing series pairing an MLS club with a Liga MX side.

The inaugural event aligns with Mexican Independence Day, bringing fans more than just a match—complete with Mariachi, Folklórico performances, and a festive stadium atmosphere that highlights the passion shared on both sides of the border. The victor will lift the Baja Cup Trophy, which stays in their possession until the rematch next year.

If you enjoyed reading this article, please consider following me on Instagram @sdfcnation and check out my website. 

Dmitry Anisimov

Dmitry Anisimov is a San Diego native who played soccer up to the college level when he represented the SDSU Men’s Club Soccer team. Growing up in San Diego, Dmitry is a fan of all the home teams but he specifically couldn’t wait until San Diego got an MLS team. Once that dream became reality, Dmitry married his love for writing and the game of soccer to portray a voice of the San Diego soccer community. There is a deep-rooted love of soccer culture in San Diego and Dmitry hopes to bring it to light through his pre and post-game coverage of all things San Diego FC.